Trump's Executive Order on Scientific Integrity Sparks Controversy

President Trump has issued an executive order aiming to restore "gold standard" scientific integrity in federal research. The directive mandates transparency, reproducibility, and falsifiability in scientific studies, requiring open access to data and negative results. It also safeguards against political interference and promotes unbiased peer review.
The order has drawn sharp criticism from some scientists, including Michael Mann, who warns it could "destroy American science as we know it." A group called Stand Up for Science has even invoked comparisons to Nazi Germany, claiming the new rules threaten scientific progress. However, supporters argue the measures are necessary to correct years of biased research, particularly in areas like climate change and the COVID-19 pandemic.
The executive order addresses concerns over flawed models and assumptions, such as the overuse of the RCP 8.5 climate scenario, which relies on highly unlikely projections. It emphasizes the need for credible, reliable evidence in federal decision-making, rejecting overly precautionary or ideological-driven conclusions.
While some view the order as a return to scientific rigor, others see it as an attack on climate science and progressive policies. Regardless, the debate underscores the growing tension between scientific integrity and political influence in shaping public policy.

Published: 6/3/2025